All news
Witness Need Not Personally Assert Loss of Reputation for Defamation Cognizance
News2 min read

Witness Need Not Personally Assert Loss of Reputation for Defamation Cognizance

L

LawWorld

The Karnataka High Court has held that a court taking cognizance of a criminal defamation complaint under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 need not require an independent witness to state in his own estimation that the complainant's reputation was lowered. Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde passed the ruling on November 12, 2026.

According to the bench, the personal belief of the independent witness regarding lowering of reputation is not a prerequisite for the defamation complaint to proceed. A criminal defamation case can therefore be taken up for cognizance even when the witness has not offered his own assessment that loss of reputation occurred.

Court rejects personal belief test

In the order, the court drew a distinction between the testimony of the witness about the facts and the witness's subjective view of their effect on reputation. The latter is unnecessary at the stage when the court decides whether to take cognizance. The absence of a statement that reputation stood lowered in the witness's estimation does not by itself prevent the court from acting on the complaint.

On this point, the ruling addresses the threshold that magistrates apply while examining defamation complaints for cognizance. Under the bench's reading, insistence on a specific form of words from the witness about reputation is not contemplated for cognizance under the provision. The complaint survives that limited scrutiny even without such a personal conclusion on reputation on record.

Under the ruling, the interpretation removes a potential objection that could stall a criminal defamation complaint at the threshold for complainants. For witnesses called in support, the bench's view means their account need not include a separate assertion about loss of business reputation or general loss of reputation to sustain the complaint at that stage. For courts considering such complaints across Karnataka, the ruling provides guidance on how to assess the statements placed before them when deciding cognizance.

Magistrates will not refuse cognizance solely because the independent witness did not say he personally believed the complainant's standing was lowered.