The Supreme Court on 16 November 2026 set aside the removal of CRPF constable Mithilesh Kumar Pathak for overstaying leave by 99 days. A bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed his Civil Appeal No. 4411 of 2011 against the Union of India and others.
Pathak served as a constable in the 54th Battalion of the Central Reserve Police Force posted at Anantnag in Jammu and Kashmir. Casual leave was sanctioned to him in September 2000 on account of his wife's illness. While staying at his village in Munger district in Bihar during that leave, he claimed he developed infective hepatitis and could not return to duty in time. He rejoined duty on 19 January 2001 after expiry of the sanctioned period.
In the departmental enquiry in this service law matter, he produced medical prescriptions, pathological reports, medicine purchase receipts and a fitness certificate to support his explanation. The Enquiry Officer rejected those documents after noting that certain entries appeared written with the same pen and that the papers did not carry an outpatient department registration number. No doctor was examined. No independent verification was carried out before discarding the papers. The Commandant then ordered his removal from service. His departmental appeal and revision were rejected.
A Single Judge of the Patna High Court quashed the removal on the ground that rejection of the medical documents rested on "conjectures and surmises". A Division Bench reversed that order on the ground that the Single Judge had impermissibly re-appreciated evidence, which led to the appeal before the Supreme Court.
Medical papers needed independent verification
The bench said: "Absence from duty without prior permission may constitute unauthorised absence; however, unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous. The circumstances in which an employee remained absent, the explanation furnished, and the material supporting that explanation must be considered before determining the nature and gravity of the misconduct."
On the departmental enquiry's approach, the Court held that similarity in handwriting or ink, without any material connecting it to actual fabrication, could not sustain a finding that the papers were false. No treating doctor was summoned, no pharmacy was contacted and no hospital was asked to verify the treatment. The judgment further said: "The absence of an indoor or outdoor patient number, and the circumstance that the doctor appeared to have treated the Appellant privately while affixing his official seal to the fitness certificate, could call for clarification. These features did not, by themselves, establish either that no treatment had been received or that the documents were forged."
The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Division Bench judgment and restored the Single Judge order. It took into account the prior record cited against him, involving earlier absences of 71 days in 1994 and 175 days in 1999, and still described removal from service in the present facts as "grossly disproportionate". The force was directed to reinstate him immediately and to pay 50% of back wages for the entire period of removal along with all other consequential service benefits.
LawWorld Pro
Research, drafting and case management for the whole practice.
₹1,500 per month, or ₹12,000 per year — save 33%. 1 user, 250 active cases, 10 GB. Prices exclusive of 18% GST.
Comments
Sign in to read the discussion and share your thoughts.
Latest from LawWorld
News
View all- Karnataka High Court Quashes Rs 25,000 RTI Penalty, Finds Misuse By Serial Applicant17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Remands Customs Case For Denial Of WhatsApp Evidence And Section 138-C Certificate17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Gold Theft Case Against Jewellers, Seeks Police SOP On Theft Probes17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Maruti Suzuki Directors Over Failure To Implead Company17 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Upholds Stay of Conviction for Azam Khan, Extends Relief to Family17 Nov 2026
Articles
View all- Supreme Court Proposes Systematic Scrutiny of High Court Judgments for Gender-Insensitive Remarks17 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Confines OBC Creamy Layer PSU Ruling But Applies Principle to UPSC CSE 2025 Allocation16 Nov 2026
- Article 22(2) Clock Starts at Curtailment of Liberty, Not Formal Arrest: Supreme Court in NDPS Bail Case15 Nov 2026








