All news
Karnataka High Court Bars Deportation Without Deciding Claim of Indian Citizenship
News2 min read

Karnataka High Court Bars Deportation Without Deciding Claim of Indian Citizenship

L

LawWorld

The Karnataka High Court has barred the deportation of Abdul Rahim from the Utile Foundation at Kothanur in Bengaluru till his claim of Indian citizenship by birth is decided. Justice C.M. Poonacha issued the direction while disposing of Rahim's writ petition against the March 5, 2026 movement restriction order passed by the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer. Nationality, the bench said, must be determined through adequate procedure in accordance with law after giving the petitioner a fair and reasonable opportunity to establish his case. Authorities must act expeditiously to ascertain his nationality.

Under the restriction order, he was to remain at the Foundation until repatriation. The Officer described him as a Bangladeshi national likely to disappear and indulge in undesirable activities. Rahim said he was born in New Seemapuri, Delhi, on April 14, 1979, had lived in India for several decades and shifted to Bengaluru in 2014. He earned a living from waste management and scrap trading run as a proprietorship concern. For proof he produced a passport issued in 2018, a voter identity card issued in 2005, Aadhaar card, PAN card, driving licence and other government-issued certificates.

FRRO cited hospital record mismatch

Opposing the plea, the Officer called him a Bangladeshi national relying on fabricated and fraudulent documents. It flagged discrepancies in the birth certificates he produced in two different proceedings. The hospital named in his birth claim, the Officer said, came into existence only in December 1995 and could not have created a record for 1979. The genuineness of his father's death certificate and other documents was also disputed.

The bench recorded that a Ghaziabad court had convicted him in 2010 under Section 14A(b) of the Foreigners Act, 1946 for illegal entry, that the Allahabad High Court had later granted him bail, and that the Officer had not considered those materials while ordering repatriation. The authorities, Justice Poonacha observed, ought to have examined the documents produced and heard him before restricting his movement. Possession of passports, voter cards and similar papers did not by itself prove citizenship under Indian citizenship law, the order clarified. But the authorities could not ignore them without proper examination. Paragraph 16 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025 allows reference of the question whether a person is a foreigner to a Foreigners Tribunal, the bench pointed out. It declined to decide citizenship in writ proceedings. That question is left to the competent authorities to decide through the prescribed legal process. Deportation must wait for that finding.