All news
Supreme Court Issues Notice in ITC Plea on Inter-State Stock Transfers, Bars Coercive Steps
News2 min read

Supreme Court Issues Notice in ITC Plea on Inter-State Stock Transfers, Bars Coercive Steps

L

LawWorld

The Supreme Court on November 16 issued notice in a special leave petition filed by ITC Ltd. challenging a Telangana High Court judgment which held its inter-State stock transfers taxable under Section 3(a) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. The Court directed in the interim that no coercive steps be taken against the company for recovery of the commercial tax demand of Rs 11,59,38,020 upheld by the High Court.

At issue before the apex court is the taxability question decided against the company by the Telangana High Court. ITC Ltd. is the petitioner, challenging the Telangana High Court judgment on inter-State stock transfers of goods. That court had taken the view that the transfers fell under Section 3(a) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 as inter-State sales for the purpose of levy.

Central to the dispute is a commercial tax demand quantified at Rs 11,59,38,020. The Telangana High Court order had upheld that demand on the stock transfers in issue. The case concerns movement of goods by the company between States described as stock transfers in the proceedings before the High Court. That movement was treated as attracting tax under the provision dealing with inter-State sales.

Interim shield on Rs 11.59 crore recovery

Under the Supreme Court's interim direction, coercive recovery remains restrained while the special leave petition is pending. No coercive steps are to be taken against ITC Ltd. on the Rs 11,59,38,020 demand in the meantime. The protection is interim in nature and operates alongside the notice issued to the respondents in the petition. It preserves the position on recovery until the Court passes further orders in the matter.

With notice issued, the respondents will have an opportunity to place their case before the Supreme Court on the correctness of the Telangana High Court's reading of Section 3(a). The Court will consider the special leave petition after the pleadings contemplated by the notice are complete. The dispute over whether the inter-State stock transfers were branch transfers or inter-State sales taxable under the Central Sales Tax Act will be examined at that stage. Until then, the company retains the benefit of the direction against coercive steps on the Rs 11,59,38,020 commercial tax demand.