The High Court of Karnataka has set aside the Customs Department's Order-in-Original dated February 28, 2026 against Abdulla Nedumalayil, Yasir Mohammad and Sarafudheen P.T., with Justice B.M. Shyam Prasad sending the matter back for a limited decision on access to electronic evidence.
Issued on April 22, 2024, the Show Cause Notice followed alleged recovery of undeclared foreign currency during scheduled travel from Bengaluru to Bangkok, the order records.
Investigators had relied on WhatsApp messages and screenshots to attribute liability, but copies of that material were not made available to the noticees along with the certificate required by the statute, according to the order.
Before the adjudicating authority, the noticees said the papers supplied to them were incomplete and they could not verify or answer the digital logs without the underlying records and certification.
That defence was treated as not established, citing want of written submissions and failure to attend personal hearings, the High Court noted.
According to the bench, the record instead showed a timely e-mailed reply that specifically demanded the digital material, even if it was not handed over at the hearing or immediately after service of the notice.
On that reply, the order stated:
“This Court finds some force in the submissions by Sri Aravind V. Chavan that the reply is not considered because it is not handed over during the personal hearing or immediately after the service of Show Cause Notice but is sent by e-mail, but the underlying salient is that the petitioner’s reply has been sent by e-mail making the point that the petitioner is entitled to be served with copies of WhatsApp messages/screen shots along with the Certificate as contemplated under Section 138C of the Customs Act,”
Failure to decide that demand left a procedural gap that could expose any later confirmation of the notice to challenge, the court said.
Supply of the relied-upon electronic records with certification was part of due process before liability could be fastened, it described.
Disclosure to be decided first
Under the remand, the third respondent must take up the disclosure question as a preliminary issue before returning any fresh finding on the merits of the seizure.
For that purpose the petitioners must appear on November 30, 2026 carrying a certified copy of the High Court order and a copy of their reply dated September 11, 2025, the order directs.
The operative direction provides:
“The third respondent after hearing the petitioner shall first decide on whether he must be furnished with certain documents [WhatsApp/screenshots] along with Certificate under Section 138-C of the Customs Act and proceed to pass orders and then proceed further based on such consideration,”
No fresh adjudication on the notice can proceed until that preliminary order on furnishing is passed.
LawWorld Pro
Research, drafting and case management for the whole practice.
₹1,500 per month, or ₹12,000 per year — save 33%. 1 user, 250 active cases, 10 GB. Prices exclusive of 18% GST.
Comments
Sign in to read the discussion and share your thoughts.
Latest from LawWorld
News
View all- Karnataka High Court Quashes Rs 25,000 RTI Penalty, Finds Misuse By Serial Applicant17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Gold Theft Case Against Jewellers, Seeks Police SOP On Theft Probes17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Maruti Suzuki Directors Over Failure To Implead Company17 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Upholds Stay of Conviction for Azam Khan, Extends Relief to Family17 Nov 2026
- Probation Discharge Based on Suitability Is Not Punitive, Supreme Court Holds17 Nov 2026
Articles
View all- Supreme Court Proposes Systematic Scrutiny of High Court Judgments for Gender-Insensitive Remarks17 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Confines OBC Creamy Layer PSU Ruling But Applies Principle to UPSC CSE 2025 Allocation16 Nov 2026
- Article 22(2) Clock Starts at Curtailment of Liberty, Not Formal Arrest: Supreme Court in NDPS Bail Case15 Nov 2026








