All news
Karnataka High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Maruti Suzuki Directors Over Failure To Implead Company
News2 min read

Karnataka High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Maruti Suzuki Directors Over Failure To Implead Company

L

LawWorld

On November 13, Justice H.P. Sandesh of the Karnataka High Court quashed criminal proceedings against ten directors of Maruti Suzuki India Limited in a complaint under the Legal Metrology Act, 2009. The prosecution had been launched by the Legal Metrology Department for alleged violations of the Act.

The complaint followed an inspection conducted at the premises of R.N.S. Motors Limited, described as a dealership of the manufacturer. After the inspection, the department filed a criminal complaint naming the directors as the accused persons. The company itself was not arraigned as an accused in those proceedings.

Acting on that complaint, the Magistrate took cognizance of the alleged offences. Summons were thereafter issued directing the directors to appear and answer the charge.

Company not named, prosecution fails

Justice Sandesh held that failure to arraign the company rendered the prosecution against the directors unsustainable. A company must be made an accused before its directors can be prosecuted for offences said to have been committed by the company, the court said. For that proposition, it relied on the Supreme Court decision in Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels.

The order records the present complaint contained no pleadings sufficient to fix liability on the persons named, with no specific role attributed to each of them. Without such pleadings, directors cannot be held vicariously liable, the judge said. In view of those findings, continuation of the case against the directors would not be permissible in law.

Cognizance taken by the Magistrate was therefore set aside, along with the summons issued to the directors pursuant to that cognizance. As a result, the criminal complaint initiated after the inspection at the dealership will no longer proceed against the ten directors.

Before the bench, the challenge was to the maintainability of a prosecution that proceeds only against individuals for a corporate allegation. The department's case treated the alleged non-compliance at the dealership as attributable to the manufacturer and its management. With cognizance and summons gone, the directors will not face trial on that complaint.