All news
Karnataka High Court Quashes Rs 25,000 RTI Penalty, Finds Misuse By Serial Applicant
News2 min read

Karnataka High Court Quashes Rs 25,000 RTI Penalty, Finds Misuse By Serial Applicant

L

LawWorld

Karnataka High Court Quashes Rs 25,000 RTI Penalty Against MSIL Officer Over Misuse

Justice T.P. Vivekananda allowed a writ petition by the Public Information Officer of Mysore Sales International Limited. His order set aside the Karnataka Information Commission's December 6, 2023 direction imposing a Rs 25,000 penalty for an alleged 240-day delay in furnishing information under the Right to Information Act.

The application behind the penalty was filed on May 26, 2022. It sought records relating to government approval for creation of a Director (Marketing) post for 2021-2022, with promotion orders for 2022-2023.

At the time, the officer was working as General Manager of the state-run entity. He forwarded the query within the organisation to collect the records and supplied them on July 28, 2022.

The applicant still pursued the matter in appeal to the Commission. The Commission treated the time taken as delay and imposed the penalty.

Before the High Court, the petitioner said the penalty ignored the practical difficulty of handling an unusually large volume of requests from the same person.

Replying to the Commission's show-cause notice, the officer had cited operational constraints and the mismatch between staff available and repeated demands. The Commission rested its decision only on the calendar taken for disclosure.

62 applications in two months

The Court was told the applicant was a former union leader in the same establishment.

Between April and August 2022 the same applicant filed 62 separate applications. Most of them had already been answered by the authority.

That pattern pointed to absence of good faith, the bench said. The requests were aimed at overwhelming the public authority rather than pursuing accountability.

"By looking to the conduct of respondent No.1 in filing 62 applications within a span of about 2 months, a reasonable inference could be drawn that there is no bonafides in the conduct of respondent No.1 in filing the application after the application by misusing the provision of the RTI Act," the bench remarked in its order.

An executive appointment was the subject of the present request. It had no direct link to the applicant's own service record, which weakened the claim of personal or public need for the documents.

"The object of enactment of RTI Act is for obtaining information from the public authority for valid and genuine purpose. But now-a-days, it is seen the RTI Act is being used to harass the Public Information Officers for extraneous reasons with oblique motive," the order stated.

According to the bench, the Commission had failed to consider the officer's explanation in proper perspective. That lapse made the penalty direction legally unsustainable.

It found no "gross negligence or inordinate delay" to warrant a financial penalty. It allowed the writ petition and quashed the Commission's direction in its entirety.