On November 16, 2026, Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi stayed the impugned tax demands in petitions against the Union of India and others. The petitions challenge the Gujarat High Court's ruling on Rule 28(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017.
Notice was made returnable within four weeks. Advocate-on-Record G. S. Makker accepted and waived notice for the respondents. Senior advocates Mukul Rohatgi, Navin Pahwa and Balbir Singh appeared for the petitioners, while Additional Solicitor General N. Venkataraman appeared for the respondents.
The order said: "There shall be stay of the impugned demand(s) until further orders." It recorded no finding on the competing readings of the GST provisions. The interim protection applies to the demands under challenge rather than to GST on corporate guarantee demands generally.
Before the Gujarat High Court, the batch arose from holding-company guarantees for borrowings obtained by related companies from banks or financial institutions. The question was whether furnishing such a guarantee is a taxable supply where the guarantor receives no commission or other consideration.
The petitioners had invoked Articles 14, 19(1)(g) and 265 of the Constitution against Section 15(4) of the CGST Act and Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs circulars dated October 27, 2023 and July 11, 2024, besides the valuation rule. They had also questioned levy, valuation and application to guarantees executed before the rule was introduced. A Division Bench of Justices A. S. Supehia and Vaibhavi D. Nanavati partly allowed those petitions on August 14, 2026, sustaining the statutory framework on several points while giving relief on valuation, earlier-period demands and proceedings under Section 74.
High Court read down valuation formula
Rule 28(2), introduced on October 26, 2023, prescribes 1% of the guaranteed amount or actual consideration, whichever is higher, as the deemed value on which tax is computed, with a later amendment adding the words "per annum" with effect from the same date. The 1% figure fixes the deemed value for calculation and is not the rate of tax on the loan amount.
In the cases before it, actual charges ranged from 0.25% to 0.3%. The High Court examined the effect of compelling adoption of that benchmark despite a lower agreed charge, especially for guarantees continuing over several years. The petitioners had argued that a valuation provision could not by itself create a taxable supply and that a mandatory benchmark would produce arbitrary outcomes where the real commission was lower.
The rule was not struck down in full. Section 15(4), which permits prescribed valuation where value cannot be fixed under Section 15(1), was sustained, along with levy on guarantees given without consideration. The Court held the mandatory "whichever is higher" condition arbitrary because it left the guarantor no option to pay on actual commission or charges, and read down that phrase while retaining the remainder of the rule.
Administrative concern over possible valuation disputes could not by itself support an inflexible mechanism with arbitrary consequences, the Court said. The case will come up again after the respondents place their reply on record.
LawWorld Pro
Research, drafting and case management for the whole practice.
₹1,500 per month, or ₹12,000 per year — save 33%. 1 user, 250 active cases, 10 GB. Prices exclusive of 18% GST.
Comments
Sign in to read the discussion and share your thoughts.
Latest from LawWorld
News
View all- Karnataka High Court Quashes Rs 25,000 RTI Penalty, Finds Misuse By Serial Applicant17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Remands Customs Case For Denial Of WhatsApp Evidence And Section 138-C Certificate17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Gold Theft Case Against Jewellers, Seeks Police SOP On Theft Probes17 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Maruti Suzuki Directors Over Failure To Implead Company17 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Upholds Stay of Conviction for Azam Khan, Extends Relief to Family17 Nov 2026
Articles
View all- Supreme Court Proposes Systematic Scrutiny of High Court Judgments for Gender-Insensitive Remarks17 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Confines OBC Creamy Layer PSU Ruling But Applies Principle to UPSC CSE 2025 Allocation16 Nov 2026
- Article 22(2) Clock Starts at Curtailment of Liberty, Not Formal Arrest: Supreme Court in NDPS Bail Case15 Nov 2026








