All news
Supreme Court Restores Rs 8.70 Lakh Electrocution Compensation With Strict Liability Finding
News2 min read

Supreme Court Restores Rs 8.70 Lakh Electrocution Compensation With Strict Liability Finding

L

LawWorld

On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court restored a trial court decree of Rs 8.70 lakh with 6 per cent interest in favour of a woman who lost her right hand due to electrocution. The order set aside the Rajasthan High Court decision which had reversed the trial court decree and rejected her claim.

A Bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar heard the matter. Justice Shree Chandrashekhar authored the judgment, numbered as 2026 INSC 1216. The Bench held that suspicion cannot replace evidence in civil appeals. It said a first appellate court cannot dismiss an electrocution compensation claim merely because the incident appears doubtful.

Such doubt, the Court said, must be tested against the witnesses examined and the documents proved on record. Without that evaluation, it said, rejection of the suit has no basis in the evidence. The judgment said civil cases are governed by preponderance of probability.

High Court reversal set aside

The Bench said the party asserting a fact must show a fair degree of certainty in its favour. A mere possibility, it said, does not meet that requirement. Applying that measure to the record, the Court found the claim for compensation for electrocution established. It held that strict liability attached to the respondents for the supply-related incident.

According to the judgment, an appellate court must deal with the testimony and the material placed on record before concluding that the incident did not occur. The High Court had not carried out that exercise when it set aside the decree, the judgment said.

The result is that the woman is entitled to recover the decretal sum with interest from the respondents in terms of the trial court order. The order closes the second round of litigation over the incident and leaves the trial court decree as the enforceable adjudication between the parties. Payment is to be made in accordance with the interest rate fixed by the trial court.