All news
State Cannot Reopen Caste Status After Years of Unexplained Delay
News2 min read

State Cannot Reopen Caste Status After Years of Unexplained Delay

L

LawWorld

The Karnataka High Court Division Bench of Justices M. Nagaprasanna and Hema Kulkarni dismissed the CISF Commandant's intra-court appeal under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Court Act, 1961. The constable remains in service after nearly 14 years.

It had challenged a Single Judge's order quashing the communication that questioned his caste status. The Single Judge had said the authorities gave no explanation for the delay and could not deny him the benefit of long service.

Deputy Solicitor General of India Venkatesh M. Kharvi appeared for the Commandant, Prashant S. Hosamani for the constable and Additional Government Advocate Sharad V. Magadum for the State authorities.

Wrong list used for verification

The constable had obtained a caste verification certificate recording Hindu-Reddy community under Category III(A).

He used it to enter the CISF selection process and was appointed constable in 2009. His documents were then sent for verification.

In 2018 the jurisdictional Tahsildar confirmed the certificate and category, though by the Karnataka State list.

The post was in Central service, so eligibility turned on the Central OBC list, where that community did not figure.

Four years later the District Commissioner told the Commandant it could not support reservation in Central Government employment, about 13 years after appointment.

Before the Single Judge, the CISF and State authorities said the appointment rested on an inapplicable category and the fresh look followed a complaint. They admitted laxity in verification.

On delay the Bench said: "The learned Single Judge follows the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of DATTU S/O NAMDEV THAKUR v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS, which had clearly held that after delay of 9 years, the State could not have taken action against the appellant before the Apex Court."

That 2012 ruling of the Supreme Court on the doctrine of delay and laches was applied to disapprove adverse proceedings started after years of service without explanation.

The Single Judge had recorded: "In the present case, there is no allegation that the petitioner has either fabricated, forged or concocted the caste certificate."

The Single Judge also directed the State to build an electronic dashboard for employers to upload caste documents, fix timelines for verification and instruct officials on the State-Central list distinction.