All news
Supreme Court Acquits Haryana Double-Murder Accused, Holds Police Statements Cannot Sustain Conviction
News2 min read

Supreme Court Acquits Haryana Double-Murder Accused, Holds Police Statements Cannot Sustain Conviction

L

LawWorld

Naresh was acquitted in a Haryana double-murder case on 16 November 2026, with the Supreme Court setting aside the life sentence imposed on him. The judgment was delivered by Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh.

Two women had been killed in Haryana. The trial court had convicted Naresh for the murders and sentenced him to imprisonment for life. He appealed to the Supreme Court seeking acquittal and quashing of the conviction and sentence.

According to the bench, the conviction rested on inadmissible statements, unreliable recoveries and an incomplete chain of circumstances. Statements recorded by police under CrPC Section 161 and Section 162 cannot be used as a substitute for evidence led during trial, it said. A statement under section 161 CrPC given to the investigating officer, the Court added, could not by itself become the foundation for holding the accused guilty.

The Court said a witness hostile to the prosecution in court did not change that position. Where the witness did not support the prosecution case, the earlier police version could not be treated as substantive proof of the charge against Naresh.

Recoveries failed strict proof test

Disclosure statements made by the accused had led to the recoveries relied on by the prosecution. Such disclosure-led recoveries require strict proof under Section 27 of the Evidence Act before the court can act on them, the bench said. On the record placed before it, the Court found the recoveries in this case unreliable and refused to sustain the conviction on that material.

Prosecutors had not established a complete chain of circumstances linking Naresh to the deaths of the two women, the bench found. The gaps in that chain left the charge unproved, the Court said. While assessing the record, the bench applied the principle of parity between co-accused and held that Naresh could not be held liable alone on the same inadequate evidence.

Victim compensation for the families of the two deceased women should be taken up for consideration by the competent authority, the judgment said. With this acquittal, the conviction and life sentence recorded against Naresh stand set aside and he stands freed from the sentence.