All news
Supreme Court Holds Clarification Pleas Cannot Be Used To Supervise Execution Of Arbitral Awards
News2 min read

Supreme Court Holds Clarification Pleas Cannot Be Used To Supervise Execution Of Arbitral Awards

L

LawWorld

The Supreme Court has dismissed Royal Construction Company Pvt. Ltd.'s miscellaneous application seeking modification of its October 10, 2023 judgment in the dispute with National Projects Construction Corporation. The award-holder wanted the decision on the certified question of law to also address pending issues in execution of the arbitral award. The Court refused. It said clarification could not be used to expand that judgment into supervision of continuing execution proceedings. It said questions of amounts deposited, withdrawals, adjustment and set-off must be decided by the competent executing court and the appellate court hearing appeals from its orders.

Dated August 10, 2002, the arbitral award arising from an internationally seated arbitration had been rendered in favour of the award-holder with the sums denominated in Iraqi Dinars. By judgment dated February 24, 2015, the Court had restored the directions contained in the award after challenges before Indian courts. That judgment invoked minimal judicial intervention and cautioned against courts substituting their subjective assessment for that of the arbitral tribunal without statutory grounds for interference. The dispute then continued at the execution stage.

Rupee Conversion Order Led To Certification

On July 26, 2017, the executing court permitted discharge of the award liability in Indian Rupees at the exchange rate prevailing on September 26, 1982. It treated the latter date as the date of the underlying agreement. On challenge by the award-holder, the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court set aside the Single Judge's order. It certified a substantial question of law of general importance under Article 134A read with Article 133(1)(a) of the Constitution on the relevant date for conversion of the awarded sum from US Dollars into Indian Rupees.

The order recorded concern that the parties were still litigating over enforcement despite the long passage of time since the award. It directed the Registry to forward the judgment to the Chairman of the Law Commission of India for study of the framework governing enforcement and execution of arbitral awards. The reference seeks consideration of reforms for timely recovery where, as here, enforcement continued more than 24 years after the award.