All news
Pandemic-Era Freeze on Grant-in-Aid Posts Not a Perpetual Ban, Rules Karnataka High Court
News2 min read

Pandemic-Era Freeze on Grant-in-Aid Posts Not a Perpetual Ban, Rules Karnataka High Court

L

LawWorld

On November 18, 2026, a Division Bench of Justice D.K. Singh and Justice H. Shanthi Bhushan partly allowed the State government's appeal against a December 8, 2023 order of a single judge. The single judge had decided a petition by the Karnataka Rajya Anudanitha Shikshana Samsthegalu Okkuta.

The Bench said the State's June 10, 2020 notification, issued amid economic hardship caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, could not be read as a perpetual prohibition on filling vacancies through grant in aid in private aided educational institutions.

A communication issued in February 2023 had restricted vacancies that arose after December 31, 2015. That document, by itself, was not an independent government policy or statutory instrument imposing a blanket ban, the order said.

Under Clause 2, posts falling vacant due to retirement, death, resignation or other reasons during the financial year 2020-21 were barred from being filled. The reason given was financial constraints linked to the pandemic, the order noted.

Clause 3 said no fresh consent could be given for filling vacant posts. This could not be read as an indefinite bar on recruitment.

Read as a whole, the notification neither prescribed that cut-off date nor imposed any express permanent prohibition on recruitment in such institutions, the Bench said.

Section 52(2) of the Karnataka Education Act, 1983 lets the government sanction grant-in-aid or refuse it for good and sufficient reasons. It gives no independent power to impose a general prohibition on filling vacancies, the order said.

The findings did not mean every vacancy arising after that date must be filled. Nor were the authorities bound to sanction aid for each such post.

The government remained free to formulate an appropriate policy on sanction of aid taking into account its financial capacity, so long as the policy stayed consistent with the statute and the Rules, the order said.

That restriction had been issued without any lawful basis, the Bench said.

Prior permission still mandatory

Requests to fill grant-in-aid vacancies must be examined individually. The competent authority must look at sanctioned strength, nature and date of vacancies, existing teaching strength, student strength, staffing pattern, reservation requirements and financial implications, the order said.

Prior permission of the government for filling such vacancies remains mandatory. Private managements cannot recruit without obtaining it.

It set aside the earlier direction to the extent that direction had treated the permission requirement as a mere intimation and had confined the authority's scrutiny to compliance with the reservation roster.

Comments

Sign in to read the discussion and share your thoughts.