How GST Law in India Taxes Free Guarantees
The petitioners said a guarantee for no fee involves no supply at all. No payment changes hands, they argued, and the parent often performs no banking service. The department relied on Schedule I to the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, which treats supplies between related persons without consideration as taxable in certain cases. A holding company and its subsidiary fall in that net. Once that point was accepted, valuation became the fight. Taxpayers said value is nil because nothing was paid. The department said value cannot be nil where credit support has commercial worth. That split explains why advisories from top GST law firms in India after the 2023 clarification went different ways. Some told clients to pay on 1% and close files. Others told clients to litigate and keep assessments open. The Delhi Bench backed the department on liability and the taxpayers on method.
Rule 28(2) says where a corporate guarantee is given for a related person's borrowings, the value is deemed to be one per cent of the amount guaranteed or the actual consideration, whichever is higher. Read literally, it looks like a fixed floor. The Court refused to read it that way. A valuation rule, it said, cannot create a tax where none exists, and it cannot fix a price that ignores commercial reality. A deeming provision in delegated legislation must stay tied to the value of supply under Section 15 of the Act. Applied without regard to tenure, risk, credit rating, or whether the loan was even drawn, 1% stops being valuation and becomes a separate levy. To keep the rule inside the parent Act, the figure stays as a safe harbour and an initial presumption. The officer can start from it. The taxpayer can rebut it.
Guarantee Taxed Once, Not Every Year
The Court also settled timing. A corporate guarantee is a single supply at execution. Tax falls when the deed is signed and the promise to cover default is given. It does not recur each financial year while the loan runs. That finding hits annual 1% demands where officers multiplied the guaranteed sum by each year of tenure. The Bench said the promisor does not give a fresh guarantee every April. The service is the standing commitment, given at creation though its effects last. Time of supply therefore follows the execution date, with invoice and payment tied to that event. For guarantees already in place, arrears are limited to a one-time charge on the guarantee value as rebutted, with interest and penalty only from that point. No second levy arises if the loan is renewed without a fresh guarantee document.
Taxpayers Must Now Prove Lower Value
Reading down shifts work to evidence. A company that gave a free guarantee can now file records to show the deemed figure is too high. The Court pointed to familiar material: a bank quote for a comparable guarantee commission, a third-party fee for similar exposure, the subsidiary's credit strength, collateral already held by the lender, and a short tenure or undrawn facility. Where a parent shows that an arm's length bank would have charged far less than 1%, or nothing because the guarantee added no incremental support, the officer must consider that proof and give reasons for accepting or rejecting it. The presumption does not vanish. If the taxpayer files nothing, 1% will stand. Many readers still ask when was the GST law implemented in India — it was July 2017 — and whether old guarantees escape. They do not escape liability, but valuation for pre-amendment periods must still follow Section 15 and the general valuation rules, not an automatic 1%.
Holding companies must now list each guarantee deed, note the execution date, and decide whether to accept 1% or contest it. The related borrower, if in taxable business, can generally use the tax charged as input credit where the law permits, which softens cash cost but leaves value disputes open. Finance teams will need to match GST filings with accounting for financial guarantee contracts and with transfer-pricing reports that often price the same support at a different spread. Officers cannot make a standard addition. Each order must deal with the taxpayer's comparables and explain why they were rejected.
Delhi Breaks From Bombay, Gujarat
Other High Courts have taken other paths, which is why the Delhi order will be read closely outside the capital. Petitions before the Bombay and Gujarat High Courts raised the same questions — whether a free guarantee is a supply at all, how Rule 28(2) should apply, and whether tax can repeat each year. The Delhi Bench answered all three together: yes to taxability, rebuttable on value, once-only on timing. That middle course keeps the levy but rejects automatic arithmetic. Until the Supreme Court settles the conflict or the Goods and Services Tax Council issues a fresh clarification, taxpayers in different states face different litigation risk. The Delhi reasoning on reading down, tied to Section 15 and the limits of delegated legislation, is likely to be cited elsewhere.
The writs remain before the Court for consequential directions, and the department may seek review or appeal. For now, companies with pending show-cause notices should put valuation evidence on record, cite the execution date to resist yearly multiplication, and seek adjudication on the rebuttable basis the judgment requires.