Plants can be dismantled and reused
The test was practical. Can the plant be removed without destroying it, and can it generate power somewhere else. The Court said yes. Panels, structures, inverters, cables and transformers are fixed to the ground to hold them steady and face the sun. They are not consumed in the land. They can be unbolted, shifted and reinstalled. Size and weight counted for less than that ability.
Indian tax law has long used this test to separate movable goods from immovable property. A thing fixed to earth only for beneficial use stays movable if the fixing can be undone. A factory shed or a dam merges with the land. A solar generating system does not. The Court applied that logic to the turnkey package. Even when bought for one price covering design, supply and erection, the end product remained equipment assembled at site, not land itself.
That finding drove the rest. Once the system is movable, labour and concrete alone cannot turn the supply into a contract for construction of immovable property. Suppliers had said this since GST began. The price of GST on solar panel lots, mounting steel, cables and service charges reflected goods that arrived by truck and could leave the same way. The Court accepted that commercial reality over the label on the tender.
How GST on solar power plant worked pre-2019
Readers who entered the sector after 2019 will struggle to picture the early confusion. When GST started in July 2017, solar contracts had no special valuation entry. Officers and companies worked with general rules. Was the deal a supply of goods with installation, a mixed supply, a composite supply of services, or a works contract. Each answer meant a different rate and a different split of goods and services.
Argument over GST on solar panels built fast because panels were the largest cost. Some assessments taxed panels at the goods rate then prevailing for renewable devices and treated erection separately. Others clubbed the full turnkey value as one service. Talk around GST on solar inverters added another layer, since inverters were taxed differently from modules in trade practice. Storage made it harder still, with GST on solar batteries and GST on solar battery packs raised in audits where a plant included backup.
Notifications in late 2018 tried to calm the position. With effect from 1 January 2019, the government said a solar power generating system supplied on turnkey basis would be valued with 70% treated as goods and 30% as services. Trade called it the 70:30 rule. It gave certainty for new bids. It said nothing about plants already built and billed in 2017 and 2018. Demands that applied the 2019 split to those earlier years produced this round of litigation.
Civil works do not create immovable property
The department had leaned hard on civil work. Piles, foundations, control rooms, trenches and boundary work look like construction. Officers argued that volume proved the contract was for immovable property and therefore attracted works contract GST treatment. The Court disagreed.
Civil work in a solar plant serves the equipment. Foundations hold mounting structures against wind. Trenches protect wiring. A control room houses switchgear. None of that changes the character of the generating system. Presence of civil work alone does not convert a movable system into immovable property, the Court said. The test stays whether the plant as a whole can be detached and reused.
That point will travel beyond solar. Many energy and telecom projects mix heavy foundations with movable machines. Officers must now look at function and removability, not at how much concrete was poured. Contractors will need records showing structures are bolted rather than permanently merged, and equipment can be removed. Drawings, manuals, dismantling clauses and resale or relocation terms will carry weight in audits.
The ruling also settled the narrow point on GST on solar panel treatment against service treatment. A panel fixed with nuts and bolts for efficient generation is still a good. So is an inverter mounted on a wall for ventilation and safety. Talk of GST on solar panels as part of land misses how plants are built, repaired and sold second-hand. The Court preferred that evidence to abstract classification.
Why the 70:30 split starts January 2019
Valuation was the second half of the case. Classification aside, the figures still had to be split between goods and services. The 70:30 mechanism does it by deeming 70% of the turnkey value as goods and 30% as services. It is simple. Bidders liked it because lenders and utilities could compare prices.
The fight was over retrospectivity. Several orders applied the split to supplies made before 1 January 2019 where the taxpayer had not used it. Fresh demands followed, with interest and penalty. The Court held the mechanism took effect only on 1 January 2019. It could not be imposed on earlier transactions where the taxpayer had not opted for it.
The reasoning follows a basic tax rule. A valuation method that creates a new burden does not reach back unless the notification says so in clear terms. Here the notification fixed a start date. No words extended it backwards. Taxpayers who had paid on actual goods and services in 2017 and 2018 could not be re-assessed under a later deeming rule. The Court set aside the added tax and related penalties for the pre-2019 period before it.
For pending audits the message is direct. Check the time of supply first. If completion, invoicing and payment fall before 1 January 2019, do not apply the 70:30 split as a default. Look at contracts, invoices and books to see what passed as goods and what passed as service. Where demands were already confirmed using the later rule, those orders will have to be revisited in light of this judgment.
What developers and officers must do now
The appeal was allowed in favour of the taxpayer, with the assessment including additional demands and penalties set aside. No fresh demand on the same pre-2019 supplies under the 70:30 rule survives this order. Interest tied to that extra demand falls with it. Other issues kept open in individual cases, outside classification and retrospective valuation, still fall to the proper forum on their own facts.
EPC contractors with closed pre-2019 projects should pull out orders and appeals now. Where the only dispute is use of the 70:30 rule before its start date, a copy of Civil Appeal No. 14228 of 2026 decided on 16 November 2026 should go on record. Where classification as immovable property is also in play, site evidence on detachability should go with it. Purchase orders for modules, data sheets for GST on solar inverter units, serial numbers for GST on solar inverters in larger blocks, and treatment of GST on solar batteries where storage formed part of scope, all help show a movable system.
Buyers, lenders and utilities can close old price-adjustment clauses with more confidence. Many power purchase agreements and EPC deals from 2017 and 2018 left GST risk with one side pending clarity. That risk now narrows for the period before 1 January 2019. New tenders after that date continue under the 70:30 valuation as notified, and bidders should still price GST on solar panel supply, erection and maintenance on that basis. Tax teams should keep pre-2019 audits and post-2019 filings in separate manuals, and officers will need to pass fresh orders where earlier demands rested solely on retrospective use of the split.