The Supreme Court has set aside the sacking of Assistant Teacher Ku. Kiran. A bench of Justice Manmohan and Justice Manoj Misra restored the School Tribunal, Nagpur's 2024 order quashing her dismissal and directed Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha to reinstate her with full back wages and continuity of service.
An inquiry run by family members of the complainant and key witnesses violates the principles of natural justice even where no specific prejudice is proved, the bench held. The dispute concerned salary grants at the school in Nagpur.
Kiran was appointed in 2009, the order records. She alleged that after a 2016 government resolution gave the institution 20 percent grant-in-aid status, the management systematically kept her out of the salary grant bills. She complained to the Education Minister. Inquiries by the Education Department then held her claim to be valid, according to the case record.
The management then started disciplinary proceedings under the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools Rules. The inquiry committee was headed by a management nominee who was the brother of the school Secretary. The Secretary acted as complainant, prosecutor and witness in the case, the Court found.
Eleven of the twenty charges rested solely on the Secretary's testimony given before his own brother, the order states. The executive functioning of the school was dominated by one family, the bench said. The School Tribunal had described the proceedings as a "farce of inquiry" on the ground that those who framed the charges were also deciding them.
Tribunal revived after High Court ruling
The Bombay High Court had earlier remanded the matter and later upheld the termination. The Supreme Court said the High Court had mixed up the identities of the family members involved. It had confused the Convenor of the inquiry committee with other members of the executive committee, the bench said.
"Where the roles of complainant, prosecutor, witness and adjudicator overlap or intersect, as in the present case, the inquiry suffers from a fundamental vice, as the separation of functions essential to a fair disciplinary proceeding collapses entirely," the Court said. The bench described the defect as jurisdictional and said it could not be cured by procedural compliance or by the presence of other witnesses.
The management invoked the doctrine of necessity and said the rules on private school inquiries left it with little choice. That plea failed. Other members of the executive committee who did not belong to the Masurkar family were available to sit on the panel, the bench said.
On the test for bias, the Court said an employee need not prove actual malice or prejudice in the disciplinary inquiry procedure. What matters is whether a reasonable likelihood of bias would appear to an objective fair-minded observer, the bench said.
"The maxim Nemo Judex in Causa Sua (no one should be a judge in their own cause) constitutes a constitutional imperative under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Its infraction is not a mere procedural irregularity capable of cure, but a fundamental jurisdictional defect that vitiates the entire proceedings," the Court held.
On waiver, the bench rejected the argument that the teacher had waived objection to the committee. She had protested the Convenor's family link in her reply to the charge sheet, during the inquiry and in appeal before the School Tribunal, the order records. With the Tribunal's direction restored, the dismissal stands quashed and the school must reinstate her with back wages and continuity of service.
LawWorld Pro
Research, drafting and case management for the whole practice.
₹1,500 per month, or ₹12,000 per year — save 33%. 1 user, 250 active cases, 10 GB. Prices exclusive of 18% GST.
Comments
Sign in to read the discussion and share your thoughts.
Latest from LawWorld
News
View all- Supreme Court Protects Birbhum Stone Quarry Accused From Coercive Action Till December 521 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Orders Medical Examination Of 70-Year-Old Convict In 1981 Dumka Double Murder21 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Caps Arbitral Award To Monetary Limit Of Referred Dispute21 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Summoning Order Against Head Constable, Orders Fresh Process21 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Upholds IGST Export Refund After Omission of Rule 96(10)21 Nov 2026








