All news
Supreme Court Issues Notice On Plea To Finalise Judges Appointment MoP And Bring Collegium Under RTI
News3 min read

Supreme Court Issues Notice On Plea To Finalise Judges Appointment MoP And Bring Collegium Under RTI

L

LawWorld

On November 18, 2026, a Supreme Court bench of Justices M M Sundresh and P B Varale issued notice to the Union Government and the Secretary General of the court. The notice was on a petition by NGO Lok Prahari seeking finalisation of the memorandum of procedure governing appointments to the Supreme Court and High Courts and disclosure of Collegium minutes under the Right to Information Act, 2005. The bench allowed the petitioner to file an amended plea and called for responses on laying down objective criteria and completing the exercise in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

Lok Prahari has also sought a direction to the Chief Justice of India, on the administrative side, to start revising the procedure in line with the 2015 judgment that struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission. It wants the Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the document within one month of consultation with the Chief Justice. It has further asked that appointments follow the unanimous view of the Collegium in keeping with principles laid down in that judgment.

In court, Justice Sundresh asked if the bench should hear the matter since he is a member of the Supreme Court Collegium. He said, "Should we take this matter? Because I am also part of collegium." Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, for the petitioner, said he had no objection. "Many of your lordships will be members of collegium. That objection will never go away," Hegde said. The bench recorded the statement and said the petition could have been drafted better.

The NGO says the present framework lacks transparency and objective criteria for selection of judges. It contends the gap affects the quality of appointments and the working of constitutional courts. It says a defined selection framework is needed to protect litigants' access to justice.

MoP pending since 2015 verdict

First framed in June 1999 following directions in the Second Judges case, the memorandum of procedure lays down the process for appointments under the collegium system in India. Parliament later passed the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act in 2015 to replace that system with a body of judges and executive members. A Constitution Bench struck down the law on October 16, 2015, holding it violated judicial independence. After the verdict, the court invited suggestions to improve the system and in December 2015 asked the Centre to revise the document. Differences between the government and the judiciary delayed finalisation. In March 2017, the court turned down the Centre's proposal to let the government reject candidates on national security grounds and did not accept the plan for a permanent Collegium secretariat. In October 2017, a bench of Justices A K Goel and U U Lalit sought the Centre's response on the delay, but that order was later recalled by a bench headed by then Chief Justice Dipak Misra. Justice P S Narasimha had recused from the present petition when it came up on November 2, citing his earlier appearance as additional solicitor general in a similar dispute over the procedure. Responses from the government and the registry are awaited, and the petitioner may place its amended plea before the court.