All news
CJI Reassigns Two PIL-Type Matters From Justice Amanullah Bench Over Roster Adherence
News2 min read

CJI Reassigns Two PIL-Type Matters From Justice Amanullah Bench Over Roster Adherence

L

LawWorld

CJI Moves Two Cases From Amanullah Bench

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, in consultation with the four senior-most judges, has reassigned at least two matters from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah after that bench expanded individual disputes into nationwide public interest litigations not assigned to it under the roster.

Consulted on the decision were Justices Vikram Nath, B V Nagarathna, M M Sundresh and P S Narasimha.

The step enforces strict adherence to the roster. It follows the CJI telling judges at a full-court meeting around four weeks ago that they must decide only matters assigned to them.

At that meeting the CJI said orderly allocation of cases was essential to maintaining judicial discipline and public confidence in the administration of justice.

Judges cannot assume jurisdiction over subjects not assigned to them, he also said.

Both matters shifted from Justice Amanullah's bench had started as individual disputes before being widened to address wider systemic issues. That bench's roster does not include PILs.

One matter concerns a nationwide examination of regulatory failures in private universities. It arose as Ayesha Jain Vs Amity University Noida, a student's grievance against the private university over alleged harassment and loss of an academic year after she legally changed her name. The proceeding in that case was extended beyond the student's claim to scrutiny of private universities at a national level.

A second matter concerns unauthorised constructions and misuse of residential properties across the country. That exercise too began as an individual dispute before being extended to a pan-India scale.

As master of roster in constituting benches and allocating cases, the CJI rests the reassignment on that prerogative. It has been affirmed by the Supreme Court in Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms case (2017), State of Rajasthan Vs Prakash Chand (1997) and Jasbir Singh Vs State of Punjab (2006).

The two matters now stand moved away from the Amanullah bench.