The High Court of Karnataka has set aside the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal’s June 18, 2026 order and asked the State to consider a desk job for a selected police constable who lost his right leg while waiting for appointment. The Division Bench of Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni allowed the petition by 28-year-old Shivakumar Hiremath of Bagalkot district.
For alternative employment, the government must meaningfully consider him for second division assistant, assistant writer, junior data entry operator or any other equivalent administrative post. The post must suit his educational qualification, the cadre to which he was selected and his present physical capacity.
The amputation followed a serious road accident on November 30, 2024 while he was travelling to Raichur. He was still waiting for his appointment order then.
He had taken part in the 2019 recruitment for civil police constables in Bengaluru city with a three-year diploma treated as equivalent to a pre-university course for the recruitment. His name appeared in the final selection list, but appointment orders were withheld from him and several other selected candidates over disputes on equivalence of educational qualification. On September 21, 2023 the Tribunal upheld the equivalence under the government’s rules and told the authorities to issue appointment letters within four months.
Accident during wait for posting
Contempt proceedings were started before the Tribunal in 2024 after the direction was not carried out within the stipulated period. The Police Department issued his appointment order only on January 1, 2025 with a direction to report for duty on January 9. When the Department was informed of his condition, it refused the request for a different post.
The Bench described the matter as an extraordinary tale of administrative apathy visited upon an unfortunate selectee. It said the mishap had occurred during an unexplained delay of more than two years in issuing the appointment order. It observed that the petitioner “stands at the crossroads of two misfortunes: one inflicted by fate and the other occasioned by administrative inaction. The former has deprived him of a limb; the latter has deprived him of the timely opportunity to enter the public service”.
Rejecting him now for not meeting the physical standards for constable, without examining an alternative suitable appointment, would make a selectee who had done no wrong bear the full consequence of the delay, the Bench said. It said: “An extraordinary circumstance may warrant an extraordinary consideration, provided the remedy remains anchored to the Constitution and the governing law. A one-off situation may call for a one-off solution; not as an exception to the rule of law, but as an exercise in ensuring that the rule of law does not lose its human purpose.” He cannot now be appointed as a constable, it held, but the government should not remain indifferent to restoring to him a livelihood opportunity consistent with law.
LawWorld Pro
Research, drafting and case management for the whole practice.
₹1,500 per month, or ₹12,000 per year — save 33%. 1 user, 250 active cases, 10 GB. Prices exclusive of 18% GST.
Comments
Sign in to read the discussion and share your thoughts.
Latest from LawWorld
News
View all- Supreme Court Protects Birbhum Stone Quarry Accused From Coercive Action Till December 521 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Orders Medical Examination Of 70-Year-Old Convict In 1981 Dumka Double Murder21 Nov 2026
- Supreme Court Caps Arbitral Award To Monetary Limit Of Referred Dispute21 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Quashes Summoning Order Against Head Constable, Orders Fresh Process21 Nov 2026
- Karnataka High Court Upholds IGST Export Refund After Omission of Rule 96(10)21 Nov 2026








