All news
Gratuity Cannot Be Paid While Criminal Trial Pends Despite Departmental Exoneration
News2 min read

Gratuity Cannot Be Paid While Criminal Trial Pends Despite Departmental Exoneration

L

LawWorld

The Supreme Court Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi dismissed Bikram Chand Rana's appeal against the Himachal Pradesh Road Transport Corporation. It held gratuity cannot be released while a criminal case on the same allegations is still pending, though the departmental inquiry ended in his favour. Rule 69(1)(c) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 is a statutory bar, the Court said, and it lasts until departmental or judicial proceedings end with final orders. The ruling affirms the Himachal Pradesh High Court judgment of 23 April 2022 refusing release of terminal benefits.

Rana joined the Corporation as a Clerk in 1979, became Senior Assistant in 2000 and retired on 28 February 2009. He figured as an accused in FIR No. 140/2006 over the 2006 Combined Pre-Medical Test question-paper leak, registered under Sections 406, 418, 420 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The Corporation started separate departmental proceedings under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, alleging a role in the leak and breach of Rule 3 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. The Inquiry Officer found no evidence to establish his involvement. The charges were held not proved by order dated 28 May 2015. The Corporation gave only provisional pension and withheld gratuity and other terminal benefits because the criminal trial was still pending. His service case before the Himachal Pradesh State Administrative Tribunal was transferred to the High Court. The Single Judge declined relief, and the Division Bench upheld that refusal.

Departmental relief does not lift bar

Before the Supreme Court, the appellant argued the word "or" in Rule 69(1)(c) meant the end of either departmental or judicial proceedings was enough to allow payment. He relied on Babu Manmohan Das Shah & Ors. vs. Bishun Das, 1967 (1) SCR 836. The Bench rejected that reading. It said the provision bars payment. The word "or" widens the bar to either kind of proceeding; it does not give an alternative route to release. The Court also rejected reliance on Rule 9(1) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, holding it comes into play only after proceedings conclude. It called for expeditious disposal of the pending criminal trial arising from the 2006 leak allegations.