All news
Centre Urges Supreme Court To Limit Private Universities Probe To Individual Complaint
News2 min read

Centre Urges Supreme Court To Limit Private Universities Probe To Individual Complaint

L

LawWorld

On November 19, 2026, the Union government asked a three-judge Bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath to reconsider earlier orders that had turned a 2025 writ petition by student Ayesh Jain against Amity University into a countrywide inquiry into private universities.

The petition alleged refusal to record a change of name in the university rolls despite production of the required documents. The student said the request was to change the first name from the traditionally Hindu-sounding ‘Khushi’ to ‘Ayesha’, and complained of harassment, taunts over the decision and being barred from attending classes.

For several months the matter was heard by a Bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah. That Bench set up a committee to examine whether the allegations disclosed any criminal offence or civil wrong and at the same time widened the case beyond an individual grievance into an examination of the circumstances of setting up, regulation, functioning and concessions granted to private universities.

Despite substantial hearing before that combination, the case has since been allocated to a new combination headed by the senior-most puisne judge. The fresh hearing before the reconstituted Bench took up the fallout of the expanded adjudication.

Government cites 40,000-page state reports

Additional Solicitor General K.M. Natraj, appearing for the government, said States had been required to file voluminous status reports running to 40,000 pages each. He submitted that scrutiny should remain confined to grant of relief to the student, if deserved, and not proceed as a nationwide enquiry.

The law officer questioned the mandamus on States to look into the functioning of “each and every private university” within their respective jurisdictions. Attention was drawn in particular to the order passed in November 2025 seeking details from the Centre and the States on the background and provisions of laws leading to the establishment of all private, non-government and deemed-to-be universities.

By that order, the previous Bench had directed the Centre, the States and the University Grants Commission to disclose the steps taken to ensure that private universities kept their promise to function on a ‘no profit, no loss’ basis. It had also sought full disclosure of benefits granted by the Centre and the States, including the terms of allotment of land and preferential treatment given to the institutions.

The new Bench agreed to look into the submissions made on behalf of the government. In the meantime the committee enquiring into the student’s allegations was allowed time till the end of December to submit its final report.