All news
Supreme Court Dismisses Revenue SLP Against Quashing Of Reassessment, Keeps Law Open
News2 min read

Supreme Court Dismisses Revenue SLP Against Quashing Of Reassessment, Keeps Law Open

L

LawWorld

The Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue's special leave petition in ITO 3(2)(1) & Anr. v Rinku R Rai against the Bombay High Court order quashing reassessment for Assessment Year 2015-16.

Delay was condoned, but the bench said the impugned order did not warrant interference. It expressly kept the question of law open.

Before the High Court, the assessee had challenged a reassessment notice dated 31 March 2021 issued under Section 148 and a final assessment order dated 25 March 2022.

Reopening beyond four years from the end of the relevant year, the assessee said, lacked sanction from the competent authority under section 151.

Approval, according to the assessee, had come from the Additional Commissioner, Range 3(2), Mumbai, while the statute required sanction from the Principal Chief Commissioner, Chief Commissioner, Principal Commissioner or Commissioner.

Against the final order, a separate ground said the Assessing Officer had finalised the assessment without first issuing a draft assessment order under Section 144B(1)(xvi).

That step was mandatory under the faceless assessment procedure, the assessee argued, and its omission made the final order unsustainable.

Revenue conceded both procedural lapses

In the High Court, the Revenue's counsel drew attention to the department's affidavit-in-reply dated 24 June 2022.

Counsel acknowledged the assessee's version on the sanctioning authority and did not dispute that no draft assessment order had gone to the petitioner.

Quashing of the notice and the final order passed on that basis was the relief sought before the High Court.

On those admitted facts, the High Court held the notice to be clearly without jurisdiction and quashed and set it aside.

Defective approval was treated as the jurisdictional defect, with absence of the draft order as an additional ground affecting the final assessment.

For this assessee, the dismissal leaves the High Court's quashing undisturbed.

The Supreme Court did not itself decide the issues of approval or draft order under the Income-tax Act, 1961.