All news
Supreme Court Issues Notice On Challenge To ITC Denial Under Section 16(2)(c) CGST Act
News2 min read

Supreme Court Issues Notice On Challenge To ITC Denial Under Section 16(2)(c) CGST Act

L

LawWorld

Supreme Court Issues Notice in Sumetco Alloys Plea Against Section 16(2)(c) ITC Bar

Sumetco Alloys has approached the Supreme Court against a Rajasthan High Court judgment which rejected its challenge to the constitutional validity of Section 16(2)(c) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act. Notice has been issued on the petition. The provision denies input tax credit to the recipient where the supplier has failed to deposit the tax collected with the government.

According to the petition, buyers who paid the tax component to suppliers lost credit because the amount was not deposited further. It says satisfaction of Section 16(2)(c) was treated as a prerequisite, so default at the supplier's end led to denial at the recipient's end despite payment of consideration with tax. The question now is whether such denial can sustain against bona fide purchasers who cannot control deposit.

Tripura ruling stayed, January date fixed

For now, the Tripura High Court ruling on the same clause remains stayed. That court had read down Section 16(2)(c) to protect bona fide recipients from denial of input tax credit arising solely from the supplier's failure to deposit tax. The stay continues while the Supreme Court considers the contrary view taken by the Rajasthan High Court.

Against the Tripura judgment, the Revenue has filed a special leave petition. That petition is listed for final disposal on January 21, 2027. The Revenue told the Court that a resolution through the GST Council would require significant time. The Court then fixed the Revenue petition for hearing and disposal on that date without waiting for that process.

Notice in the Sumetco Alloys matter seeks response to the challenge against the Rajasthan dismissal, while the January listing will take up the Revenue appeal against the read-down ruling for final disposal. The outcome will decide whether credit denial under section 16 2 of cgst act for supplier non-deposit applies without exception or protects recipients who paid tax but cannot compel deposit.